Posts

Undergraduate Teaching in the Study of Religion

This brief article details some reflections of mine after having taught as a graduate student on an undergraduate Religious Studies module for the last four years. The views here are my own and do not reflect the institution where I taught. Between October 2018 and July 2019, I had the opportunity to teach full-time on an undergraduate Religious Studies module at a university in the North West of England. It was called: “The Study of Religion: An Introduction” and was delivered to first-year Theology and Religious Studies students. For three years before that, I had given occasional lectures and tutored during weekly seminars for the same Religious Studies module and another titled “Global Perspectives in Christianity”. The responsibilities that I had during my teaching posts included weekly lectures, seminars, and tutorials, grading assignments, delivering study-skills sessions, and administration. Moreover, I was given the chance to adapt the Study of Religion module slightly in ...

The Study of Religion and the Problem of Institutional Racism

In May 2016, Jay L. Garfield and Bryan W. Van Norden wrote an opinion piece for the New York Times which challenged the exclusion of non-western voices in Anglophone philosophy departments ( https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/11/opinion/if-philosophy-wont-diversify-lets-call-it-what-it-really-is.html ). They suggested that such practices of exclusion rested upon institutional racism which had its foundation in western colonialism and normativity. The exclusion of, say, Buddhist philosophical voices from departments of philosophy were/are always value judgement calls – calls which suggested that Buddhist thinkers were not engaged in activity that was completely rational and/or that the methods used by Buddhist thinkers were/are not completely rational (Garfield, 2017, xviii). I do not wish to engage in a systematic examination of study of religion departmental biases here; however, I do believe it is justified to suggest that similar institutional racism exists within our departments...

The Failure of Corbynism's New Type of Politics

What did it? Did Labour lose in 2019 because of Corbyn or Brexit? Answers to this question tend to reflect an ideological divide within the Labour Party. Those who tend to be on the right of the Party, and who were not supporters of Corbyn, suggest that the disastrous result of 2019 was mainly the fault of the leader. Conversely, those who are on the left of the Party, and who were supporters of Corbyn, suggest that Brexit, in particular, Labour’s second referendum policy, was the main cause of Labour’s defeat. This latter group often mention that Corbyn was a variable in 2017 when the Labour Party did much better than expected, and in 2019 and so blame cannot be placed primarily at his door. While I identify as being on the left of the Labour Party and have consistently supported Corbyn during the most difficult years of his leadership, it is not true to suggest that the Corbyn variable was the same in 2019 as it was in 2017. That is, the Corbyn of 2019 was different from the ...

Does Russell McCutcheon require realism?*

Kevin Schilbrack (2020) claims that for readings of religion to have academic value, they must be able to demonstrate that they are accurate. This, he further claims, requires a realist ontology where the accuracy of arguments depend on their ability to hook up to an objective reality, which, regardless of the time and place the researcher finds themselves, presents itself to us. This being the case, Schilbrack contends that Russell McCutcheon’s non-realist reading of religion is meaningless as if it is true, it could only be so if it pointed to an objective fact about religion; though, if this is the case, then the idea that religion is non-realist falls apart. Schilbrack believes this series of logical inferences produces a reductio ad absurdum of McCutcheon’s position which he cannot escape. However, there are numerous reasons which can be offered which not only provide McCutcheon with an escape but which also demonstrate that, conversely, it is realist arguments which fall into a...

A Response to Kevin Schilbrack’s ‘A metaphysics for the study of religion: A critical reading of Russell McCutcheon’

Introduction In this essay, I respond to Kevin Schilbrack’s (2020) realist critique of Russell McCutcheon’s non-realist theory of religion. Instead of non-realist constructions of religion being metaphysically flawed, I argue that  Schilbrack’s realist reading is both logically inconsistent and question-begging. Following the structure of Schilbrack’s essay, I begin by outlining his primary position and then move on to challenge two realist assumptions which underpin it. First, I challenge Schilbrack’s realist epistemological assumption that a non-realist reading of religion requires a realist epistemology, grounded in a realist ontology, if it is not to fall into meaningless relativism. Second, I raise several questions concerning the critical realist assumption that it is metaphysically and logically possible to maintain the co-existence of constructed and unconstructed realities. After challenging these metaphysical standpoints, I engage with the heart of Schilbrack’s essa...

Marx and Religion: Seminar Script

My aim here is to spark a discussion; not to describe, in extraneous detail, Marx’s theory of religion. However, some basic description of my understanding of Marx’s thought is needed to know where I am coming from if a discussion is going to be possible. So, I will start with a summarised account of Marx’s theory of religion before moving onto a series of critical questions which arose for me from the reading, and which I hope will be of interest. I was wishing to write something short and informal; however, it seems that I am incapable of doing either. So, I apologise in advance, as what I am about to say might be a bit dry. * There are many aspects of Marx’s thought which help define his theory of religion – such as it is. Though, arguably the most defining characteristic, and a good starting point for us, is Marx’s insistence that if one wishes to understand religion, one must study the social context which gave rise to it. In this sense, Marx’s theory shares characteristic...